Author |
Topic: [Mafia] D5 - Revenge of the Werewolves |
3106 replies
|
|
Ivelin not killing on N1 was interesting.
I was thinking SK when we had the 2nd kill. I was assuming that both kills going to Rocco for night 1 was plausible, then at a pinch both kills to Andy.
|
|
|
by the way Jeremy next time you are VT can you not hell for 48 hours straight about who you want to lynch like you have implied knowledge - then change your mind at the last minute :)
|
|
|
Kirsty calling you a knob was a great townslip though :))
Felt that was pretty genuine rage, felt strong town on Kirsty after that lol
|
|
|
Quote ( Gareth Griffiths @ December 23rd 2015,14:11:19 ) Eduardo ( Grocer ) - deliver some milk, steaks, eggs and wine to Freddie.
Why did I never receive this meal?
|
|
|
Well done Sam as well. I really did agree with you on Freddie :) made suspicious when you backed off it tho
|
|
|
I need to focus on my reads, its been a while and still rusty but trying ever so much to play a different game from how I use to play a year or so ago.
overall a good game and I enjoyed it. in Particular as it is now two town roles in a row and it breaks my scum role jinx. that said i will always play a bit scummy to some. to me its just good old honest cop work asking questions and pushing pushing pushing
my game is up next and will launch it sometime within the next week...
Garteh many thanks for letting me play and I enjoyed it
good win town :-)
|
|
|
my crumbs btw
Quote ( Andy Smith @ December 5th 2015,20:36:23 ) Quote ( Kirsty Ridley @ December 5th 2015,17:27:24 )
what is the general opinion of the flock?
Quote ( Andy Smith @ December 6th 2015,16:28:28 ) Or should I beat around the proverbial burning bush?
Quote ( Andy Smith @ December 8th 2015,14:59:49 ) can people please answer questions, god give me strength... sheeeeesh
|
|
|
Quote ( Phil Maunder @ December 23rd 2015,15:20:59 ) by the way Jeremy next time you are VT can you not hell for 48 hours straight about who you want to lynch like you have implied knowledge - then change your mind at the last minute :) I was dead wrong about Sam, but I did get exactly what I wanted out of my play, which was for the Tracker to find scum, and I knew the Tracker wasn't me nor Sam.
|
|
|
Quote ( Gareth Griffiths @ December 23rd 2015,14:11:27 )
This was my first closed game as mod. Feedback is welcomed on how it went
Game was good, could have made Alex a role blocking wolf.
Ivelin couldn't kill on N1? Until he saw a wolf kill right?
I had a scum gut feel in him since the start of the game, even said it on the qt.
|
|
|
Quote ( Andy Smith @ December 23rd 2015,15:26:30 ) overall a good game and I enjoyed it. in Particular as it is now two town roles in a row and it breaks my scum role jinx. that said i will always play a bit scummy to some. to me its just good old honest cop work asking questions and pushing pushing pushing I actually figured this out from last game, and you were my biggest town read this game, even without seeing your crumbs.
|
|
|
Because of Rocco's slip I thought there was a good chance that a tracker / watcher would have seen the N1 kill.
I thought it was you by the way you were carrying on but you were suspicious of Sam from during day 1 so ti was what just held me back in the end.
Had a strong town read on Sam for various reasons all game so determined to play that hunch.
I was strong town on Tim from the start as well until that last minute band wagon on me. Id love to know what valuable reaction he got when all of a sudden I'm perfectly happy to lynch anyone other than myself lol
|
|
|
Quote ( Sudeep Pednekar @ December 23rd 2015,15:36:59 ) I had a scum gut feel in him since the start of the game, even said it on the qt.
You had a scum feel on every player by the looks of QT xD
|
|
|
I think it was wrong to play the way you chose, Jeremy. You are a lot of use as town. I thought I tunneled too much!
You intentionally implied you knew something. Thats crap for town IMO.
However, I did have a town feel for Sam from the start, only his vanishing under pressure started me wondering.
When Jeremy said what he did about last game, I was sure he knew something, and by that point I was wondering a lot about Sam.
|
|
|
Quote ( Phil Maunder @ December 23rd 2015,15:21:35 ) Kirsty calling you a knob was a great townslip though :))
Felt that was pretty genuine rage, felt strong town on Kirsty after that lol LOL I was really pissed off by then, also after Freddie came in after the hammer to moan. Both were very genuine. Sorry though Freddie, I was probably a little harsher than was ok :P I love you really.
|
|
|
Also you have to mention a sharp object for a SK kill, the difference was very subtle and nobody except Jeremy picked up on it.
|
|
|
|
we should defo policy lynch Stuart though ;-P
|
|
|
Quote ( Andy Smith @ December 23rd 2015,15:42:35 ) Stuart
here here
douche left me pretty much on my own for 2 game days!
|
|
|
Quote ( Sudeep Pednekar @ December 23rd 2015,15:36:59 ) Quote ( Gareth Griffiths @ December 23rd 2015,14:11:27 )
This was my first closed game as mod. Feedback is welcomed on how it went
Game was good, could have made Alex a role blocking wolf.
Ivelin couldn't kill on N1? Until he saw a wolf kill right?
I had a scum gut feel in him since the start of the game, even said it on the qt.
Would have been an option before the start of the game. Didn't want to give any info about the SK being in the game once we began (notice the detail less kill flavours too - keeps you guessing)
|
|
|
Quote ( Freddie Higgs @ December 23rd 2015,15:38:25 ) Quote ( Sudeep Pednekar @ December 23rd 2015,15:36:59 )
I had a scum gut feel in him since the start of the game, even said it on the qt.
You had a scum feel on every player by the looks of QT xD
Not quite
|
|
|
Quote ( Sudeep Pednekar @ December 23rd 2015,15:42:22 ) Also you have to mention a sharp object for a SK kill, the difference was very subtle and nobody except Jetemy picked up on it.
I purposely kept the kills similar. If rocco had taken a shot, then a gunshot would have been heard.
|
|
|
Quote ( Kirsty Ridley @ December 23rd 2015,15:41:14 ) Sorry though Freddie, I was probably a little harsher than was ok :P I love you really.
Tis fine ahaha, After Ivelin said is everyone said what they need to say, I just presumed Iw as lynched so didn't bother checking back haha. wasn't my finest performance, but gave it all I could on my own (until Alex arrived)
Also had felt very demoralised after Gary's Lone wolf and Stuart and michael nowhere to be seen, I monologue on evil thread for most of it haha.
But thank you Gareth for keeping me company! and yes good game :)
And thank you Alex for giving me company for a short while :)
|
|
|
Quote ( Andy Smith @ December 23rd 2015,15:42:35 ) we should defo policy lynch Stuart though ;-P
EVERYGAME
|
|
|
|
Sudeep, you would be a much better player if you shouted less, you often have good points and reads. but you are so insulting no one wants to listen, you were just as insulting in the QT after you were dead, so is it a personality thing rather than a mafia thing ? :P
|
|
|
Quote ( Kirsty Ridley @ December 23rd 2015,15:53:10 ) Sudeep, you would be a much better player if you shouted less, you often have good points and reads
+1
|
|
|
Interesting to read Tim in the dead thread saying I'm 100% scum & Sudeep saying how much I was panicking.
Starting a last minute wagon on me I would do / say anything to save myself . I really, really don't know what reaction you expected.....
|
|
|
there literally aren't enough hours in the day to quote & comment on all the shit Sudeep is talking in the dead QT :)
|
|
|
I actually started a post of quotes, then realised how much was shit and just deleted and posted that he should play differently instead :P
|
|
|
Quote ( Kirsty Ridley @ December 23rd 2015,15:53:10 ) Sudeep, you would be a much better player if you shouted less, you often have good points and reads. but you are so insulting no one wants to listen, you were just as insulting in the QT after you were dead, so is it a personality thing rather than a mafia thing ? :P
Competitive rage thing
|
|
|
Been lynched on day 1, four times so far. Twice as VT, twice as Seer.
|
|
|
It's because you just do everyone's head in :)
|
|