| Author |
Topic: [MAFIA] Firefly Multirole |
3587 replies
|
|
|
@Davi can you tell me what your reads are atm? How can I persuade you into voting scum aka Armin?
|
|
|
|
Quote ( Sudeep Pednekar @ October 17th 2021,13:50:01 ) This sounds like non sense, all of the 4 you have mentioned have posted more meaningful content than Jimmy, who has done nothing in the entire game, being useless as usual. There is absolutely nothing in 563 or 556 that would read Jimmy as town.
You can have a different POV btw, but that was my impression and you can have another one if you want.
|
|
|
|
Quote ( Quentin Rieg @ October 17th 2021,13:54:58 ) You can have a different POV btw, but that was my impression and you can have another one if you want.
Jimmy's contribution to this game is comparable to Brad's IMO. Like Sudeep said, it's hardly enough material to consider him town.
|
|
|
|
Quote ( Richard Robin Paukson @ October 17th 2021,13:39:56 ) Irony is dead.
In any case, what haven't I answered? Do you read the thread Sudeep? If yes,I find it very suspicious to not answer.
If no, you may go back and read it. And answer of course.
Anyway, for some reason, I don't really care if you answer at all so I am not going back to find the questions and quote them for you. Because this way you will give an answer but you will keep missing many posts that might be helpful for you.
If you need any help and you don't feel comfortable with how the game evolves...
|
|
|
|
Quoting Sudeep and not Richard.
|
|
|
|
Quote ( Richard Robin Paukson @ October 17th 2021,14:06:40 ) Jimmy's contribution to this game is comparable to Brad's IMO.
In terms of quantity, maybe, but one of them is trying to help while the other is constantly talking to Ricardo and posting random things.
|
|
|
|
Quote ( George Togas @ October 17th 2021,14:08:36 ) Do you read the thread Sudeep? If yes,I find it very suspicious to not answer.
If no, you may go back and read it. And answer of course.
Anyway, for some reason, I don't really care if you answer at all so I am not going back to find the questions and quote them for you. Because this way you will give an answer but you will keep missing many posts that might be helpful for you.
If you need any help and you don't feel comfortable with how the game evolves...
You accuse Ric of being useless for town yet you can't even bother to highlight the things you find suspicious?
I'm fine with policy lynching George from now on.
|
|
|
|
Quote ( George Togas @ October 17th 2021,14:08:36 ) Do you read the thread Sudeep? If yes,I find it very suspicious to not answer.
If no, you may go back and read it. And answer of course.
Anyway, for some reason, I don't really care if you answer at all so I am not going back to find the questions and quote them for you. Because this way you will give an answer but you will keep missing many posts that might be helpful for you.
If you need any help and you don't feel comfortable with how the game evolves...
Okay I didn't want to go on this rant but you've asked for it now.
Yes I read the thread. You haven't asked anything. In fact you've continued to not answer my own questions.
Saying stuff like I have answered that already isn't good enough. When someone asks for an explanation you explain it again or the least you can do is re quote what you mean when you say "I have answered it already." It's always better for the person to explain what they meant instead of me assuming something from your post and interpreting your reasons and that leading to wrong conclusions further down the line.
So when you accuse others of not answering stuff it comes across as extremely rich.
You apathetic attitude isn't fit for this game, change it or don't sign up for future games.
|
|
|
|
Quote ( Quentin Rieg @ October 17th 2021,14:11:04 ) In terms of quantity, maybe, but one of them is trying to help while the other is constantly talking to Ricardo and posting random things.
It's not like his posts are helping much. Can you bring out some examples where he contributed something meaningful? I know that "trying" is subjective but upon looking through the thread, I can see one longer cluster of posts on Friday but even that didn't really provide much relevant information.
|
|
|
|
I am asking to be replaced if possible.
|
|
|
|
Quote ( Amitesh Patnaik @ October 17th 2021,12:35:11 ) I thought the whole defining his reads (the whole Davi being the stronger read thing) was slightly scummy.
You're just repeating yourself. What is scummy about it? What is the possible scum motivation behind me presenting an opinion?
Quote ( Amitesh Patnaik @ October 17th 2021,12:35:11 ) It's just a feeling from the way he is expressing himself. And his whole attitude to reading others seems very unfounded. I am aware people can be new and do well in Mafia, but I think that's not the case with George. He is a confused town.
He isn't confused. He's being apathetic. What parts of his posts come off as being confused? What is he confused about?
|
|
|
|
##Unvote
Do what you said it's not advisable.
Vote for me because as a townie I am not helpful.
The exact same thing I said about Ric and you reacted ssying it's not the right approach
|
|
|
|
##Unvote
Sorry,it seems that I shouldn't join as Sudeep said (not directly but by saying not to join again in the future)
Good luck and enjoy the game with 1 townie lynched for the good of the town...
|
|
|
|
Lets make it easier for you...
##vote George
|
|
|
|
Quote ( George Togas @ October 17th 2021,13:24:44 ) 2nd is Sudeep as he also skips answering.
Okay George.
If that is your case.
I am gonna remind you for the third time.
Quote ( Amitesh Patnaik @ October 15th 2021,15:23:46 ) George, do you still think Ric should be lynched regardless of his alignment? And why?
Now can I get an answer?
|
|
|
|
|
Quote ( Sudeep Pednekar @ October 17th 2021,14:26:03 ) You're just repeating yourself. What is scummy about it? What is the possible scum motivation behind me presenting an opinion?
Presenting your opinion is fine. You have been saying something he hasn't said and have been constantly after him. I found that mildly scummy.
Quote ( Sudeep Pednekar @ October 17th 2021,14:26:03 ) He isn't confused. He's being apathetic. What parts of his posts come off as being confused? What is he confused about?
That has been answered. Ric asked about a thousand times.
|
|
|
|
Quote ( George Togas @ October 17th 2021,14:31:22 ) Lets make it easier for you...
##vote George
Seriously George.
You are starting to get annoying. Suicide votes don't really look good, you know. And they are the least helpful in most cases.
This is just a waste of votes, and doesn't really prove alignment.
|
|
|
|
Quote ( Amitesh Patnaik @ October 17th 2021,14:39:29 ) Presenting your opinion is fine. You have been saying something he hasn't said and have been constantly after him. I found that mildly scummy.
It's my opinion of what he has said. I'm not saying he has said so and so.
Constantly been after him? Okay so I guess I shouldn't try to get someone I find scummy lynched. That isn't the point of the game anyway, right?
|
|
|
|
Quote ( Sudeep Pednekar @ October 17th 2021,14:44:48 ) It's my opinion of what he has said. I'm not saying he has said so and so.
Constantly been after him? Okay so I guess I shouldn't try to get someone I find scummy lynched. That isn't the point of the game anyway, right?
Sudeep, if we are speaking of goals, what are you trying to prove?
I have put it on a scale to represent. 3 is Null, you are at 3.1
You are free to ask questions, and I am free to analyse and have an opinion, don't I?
Why are you so concerned that I think you are null scum?
Why is it making you so uncomfortable?
|
|
|
|
Quote ( Amitesh Patnaik @ October 17th 2021,14:43:41 ) That has been answered. Ric asked about a thousand times.
I asked about it a thousand times you are right.
It hasn't been answered.
|
|
|
|
Also death to all self voters.
|
|
|
|
George wtf are you doing ?? You joined, you're a player, so help us finding who is scum and stop crying on Ric now.
|
|
|
|
|
|
Quote ( Ricardo Antunes @ October 17th 2021,15:11:23 ) Also death to all self voters.
I play God not to be depressive and your friend in the same time.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Quote ( Amitesh Patnaik @ October 17th 2021,14:34:10 ) Now can I get an answer? Quote ( Amitesh Patnaik @ October 17th 2021,14:34:10 )
Quote ( Amitesh Patnaik @ October 15th 2021,15:23:46 )
George, do you still think Ric should be lynched regardless of his alignment? And why?
Now can I get an answer?
Quote ( George Togas @ October 15th 2021,11:42:02 ) And I say real scums, because by saying Ric is scum, I don't mean he is not town. It's just his play that I find not helful for the town no matter what he is.
To be frank, I'd prefer to start the game with 1 townie less than having one chaos creator inside the town. That's why I won't regret if Ric is town and D1 lynched.
I had already answered.
|
|
|
|
Quote ( Richard Robin Paukson @ October 17th 2021,11:03:56 ) What do you mean? Which conversation? Whose responses?
Just noticed this question, sorry for not seeing Richard the page changed :P
I'm talking about this:
Quote ( Ricardo Antunes @ October 16th 2021,20:33:25 ) Quote ( Quentin Rieg @ October 14th 2021,21:01:43 )
Mate the game just started, why are you so impatient ? I said that I don't want to put the pressure on someone with literally no reason and you conclude that I will wait for everyone to get killed one by one ?
Which was not even what started this conversation? I'm assuming he is referring to this post when he says this:
Quote ( Quentin Rieg @ October 13th 2021,17:47:56 )
Why would I put someone under pressure without scum-reading him ?
But that was ages ago, so why defend it now? It just seems really weird that the initial post was not even the one being defended here, instead an older one. But WORSE THAN THAT is that Richard didn't even pick up on that either! (altough I'll concede that since I stepped in after Quentin's post)
Did you not notice he was defending something completely different?
|
|
|
|
Quote ( Quentin Rieg @ October 17th 2021,16:04:30 ) so help us finding who is scum I am trying. But most of you (not all) seem to not care and don't understand.
I think I read somewhere in this thread of a 24% town win. Not going back to dig it up. If this is right, then you people should start wondering what the hell do you expect to happen here when you keep doing the same things like in every other game.
I bet all my money to Mafia.
If the above percentage is wrong, sorry for this comment.
|
|
|
|
My request for a replacement stands
<div>
My self vote stands</div>
|
|
|
|
Quote ( Amitesh Patnaik @ October 17th 2021,14:49:36 ) Sudeep, if we are speaking of goals, what are you trying to prove?
I don't understand something so I'm asking you about it. How you got to a certain conclusion, and you aren't being able to explain it. Which is sus.
Quote ( Amitesh Patnaik @ October 17th 2021,14:49:36 ) You are free to ask questions, and I am free to analyse and have an opinion, don't I?
I didn't say you can't have an opinion. I'm asking you how to got to that conclusion.
Quote ( Amitesh Patnaik @ October 17th 2021,14:49:36 ) Why are you so concerned that I think you are null scum?
Why is it making you so uncomfortable?
You're cute for thinking that a null scum read from you could make me uncomfortable.
I'm not uncomfortable, I'm trying to understand your thought process.
Before you ask why is that suspect, it's because it seems like you're struggling to have scum reads so you're just putting some stuff together and presenting it as a scum read. While there is no real substance behind it.
|
|
Deutsch
Español
Română
Italiano
Português
Português
Français
Polski
Русский
Български
Македонски
Српски
Nederlands
Vlaams
Suomi
Lietuvių
Čeština
Magyar
Eesti keel
Slovenčina
Türkçe
Shqip
Ελληνικά
Hrvatski
Bahasa Melayu
Dansk
Pirate
