Page [12 3 ... 7 8 9 » Quick go to page:
Author Topic: Change the stars 250 replies
Kirsty Ridley
(Group Amateur - 59)



Posts: 7849
  Country:
England 
Certified: 
Like this post (83)   Dislike this post (15)
Old post #1 posted Dec 4th 2014, 19:40:36 Quote 
I think that there is a better way to do the stars ;)

1 star =1 rookie race
2 stars =1 ama race
3 stars = 1 pro race
4 stars = 1 master race
5 stars = 1 elite race
6 stars = more than 50 elite races


I think its good to see how far people have got, not how many races they did.
I also think if you managed 50 races in elite, it says pretty much the same as 150 races, you are obviously good at the game ;)


Vote with thumbs :)
Mairo Toom
(Group Amateur - 34)



Posts: 12780
  Country:
Estonia 
Certified: 
Like this post (5)   Dislike this post (0)
Old post #2 posted Dec 4th 2014, 19:41:35 Quote 
You would still live with 3 stars.
Alin Costrasuc
(Group Pro - 15)


Posts: 10928
  Country:
Romania 
Certified: 
Like this post (0)   Dislike this post (0)
Old post #3 posted Dec 4th 2014, 19:42:01 Quote 
I would have 4.
Janne Väänänen
(Group Pro - 21)


Posts: 4888
  Country:
Finland 
Certified: 
Like this post (1)   Dislike this post (0)
Old post #4 posted Dec 4th 2014, 19:42:19 Quote 
Extra star for me? Yes!
Kirsty Ridley
(Group Amateur - 59)



Posts: 7849
  Country:
England 
Certified: 
Like this post (0)   Dislike this post (0)
Old post #5 posted Dec 4th 2014, 19:42:21 (last edited Dec 4th 2014, 19:57:38 by Kirsty Ridley) Quote 
I know, its not for me...just realised it doesnt really tell you a lot and seems a bit pointless. I would like to know, looking at a person posting how far they got, not how long they have been around.
Kevin Parkinson
(Group Master - 5)



GPRO Crew
Posts: 14356
  Country:
Scotland 
Certified: 
Like this post (1)   Dislike this post (7)
Old post #6 posted Dec 4th 2014, 19:42:50 Quote 
Forum search not working, Kirsty? :(
Kirsty Ridley
(Group Amateur - 59)



Posts: 7849
  Country:
England 
Certified: 
Like this post (2)   Dislike this post (0)
Old post #7 posted Dec 4th 2014, 19:43:11 (last edited Dec 4th 2014, 19:43:29 by Kirsty Ridley) Quote 
awwww don't be a spoilsport!
I did search, but they didn't quite fit. :P
Maxim Egorov
(Group Amateur - 38)



Posts: 206
  Country:
Russian Federation 
Certified: 
Like this post (10)   Dislike this post (0)
Old post #8 posted Dec 4th 2014, 19:43:12 Quote 
7 stars = magyar
Stuart Foster
(Group Amateur - 69)



Posts: 12459
  Country:
England 
Certified: 
Like this post (3)   Dislike this post (0)
Old post #9 posted Dec 4th 2014, 19:43:41 Quote 
For the second time this season I fully agree with kirsty ;)
Mehdi El Fathy
(Group Amateur - 66)


Posts: 5057
  Country:
Morocco 
Certified: 
Like this post (5)   Dislike this post (4)
Old post #10 posted Dec 4th 2014, 19:44:00 Quote 
What if this was going to be posted by a 12 Y/O Rookie?

10 thumbs down in a minute.
Alexey Manukalov
(Group Elite)



Posts: 982
  Country:
Russian Federation 
Certified: 
Like this post (1)   Dislike this post (0)
Old post #11 posted Dec 4th 2014, 19:44:12 Quote 
I think it's good as it is now. I see a huge difference between 50 and 150 races in Elite as well as between current 3 stars and 4 stars. So I'd vote no to this change.
Kirsty Ridley
(Group Amateur - 59)



Posts: 7849
  Country:
England 
Certified: 
Like this post (0)   Dislike this post (0)
Old post #12 posted Dec 4th 2014, 19:44:25 Quote 
Could you just rephrase that please Stuart, to Kirsty is Right! :P
Peter Willmore
(Group Pro - 14)


Posts: 3616
  Country:
England 
Certified: 
Like this post (0)   Dislike this post (0)
Old post #13 posted Dec 4th 2014, 19:45:04 (last edited Dec 4th 2014, 19:46:44 by Peter Willmore) Quote 
Quote ( Stuart Foster @ December 4th 2014,19:43:41 )

For the second time this season I fully agree with kirsty ;)


Firstly I suggest you see a doctor :P

Secondly I actually like Kirsty's idea :)
Stuart Foster
(Group Amateur - 69)



Posts: 12459
  Country:
England 
Certified: 
Like this post (0)   Dislike this post (0)
Old post #14 posted Dec 4th 2014, 19:45:39 (last edited Dec 4th 2014, 19:48:11 by Stuart Foster) Quote 
you like the idea of me agreeing with kirsty? or me seeing a doctor?
Peter Willmore
(Group Pro - 14)


Posts: 3616
  Country:
England 
Certified: 
Like this post (0)   Dislike this post (0)
Old post #15 posted Dec 4th 2014, 19:46:25 Quote 
lol no Kirsty's idea :)
Phil Maunder
(Group Pro - 12)



Posts: 10003
  Country:
England 
Certified: 
Like this post (2)   Dislike this post (0)
Old post #16 posted Dec 4th 2014, 19:47:26 (last edited Dec 4th 2014, 19:47:47 by Phil Maunder) Quote 
Can I just have more stars than everyone else?

(This is like being back at McDonalds)
Ajinkya Gokhale
(Group Pro - 9)



Posts: 2063
  Country:
India 
Certified: 
Like this post (0)   Dislike this post (0)
Old post #17 posted Dec 4th 2014, 19:47:41 Quote 
This way gives more meaning to the number of stars...right now it just says number of races but no means to say which league and all...thumbs up to this idea
Kirsty Ridley
(Group Amateur - 59)



Posts: 7849
  Country:
England 
Certified: 
Like this post (0)   Dislike this post (0)
Old post #18 posted Dec 4th 2014, 19:48:29 Quote 
Quote ( Alexey Manukalov @ December 4th 2014,19:44:12 )

I think it's good as it is now. I see a huge difference between 50 and 150 races in Elite as well as between current 3 stars and 4 stars. So I'd vote no to this change.

Yeah, perhaps if I had done 150 in Elite I would see this as a bad idea too lol. :)
But I often think the stars should be more about achievement than just being around.
Kevin Parkinson
(Group Master - 5)



GPRO Crew
Posts: 14356
  Country:
Scotland 
Certified: 
Like this post (0)   Dislike this post (0)
Old post #19 posted Dec 4th 2014, 19:50:23 Quote 
Quote ( Kirsty Ridley @ December 4th 2014,19:48:29 )

Quote ( Alexey Manukalov @ December 4th 2014,19:44:12 )

I think it's good as it is now. I see a huge difference between 50 and 150 races in Elite as well as between current 3 stars and 4 stars. So I'd vote no to this change.
Yeah, perhaps if I had done 150 in Elite I would see this as a bad idea too lol. :)
But I often think the stars should be more about achievement than just being around.


But "just being around" in Elite for that length of time surely is an achievement?
Kirsty Ridley
(Group Amateur - 59)



Posts: 7849
  Country:
England 
Certified: 
Like this post (1)   Dislike this post (0)
Old post #20 posted Dec 4th 2014, 19:51:22 Quote 
lol, I meant more in the other levels, getting a star for 100 races seems less of an achievement than for getting to Pro
Phil Maunder
(Group Pro - 12)



Posts: 10003
  Country:
England 
Certified: 
Like this post (0)   Dislike this post (0)
Old post #21 posted Dec 4th 2014, 19:51:22 Quote 
Hanging around like a chronic bad smell but essentially never achieving anything is all some people can do though

:|
Kevin Parkinson
(Group Master - 5)



GPRO Crew
Posts: 14356
  Country:
Scotland 
Certified: 
Like this post (1)   Dislike this post (0)
Old post #22 posted Dec 4th 2014, 19:53:47 Quote 
Quote ( Kirsty Ridley @ December 4th 2014,19:51:22 )

lol, I meant more in the other levels, getting a star for 100 races seems less of an achievement than for getting to Pro


I don't disagree with that, but removing the extra stars for long term elite managers would be the opposite of what you want.

Not against a change, but would think it needs refined.
Kirsty Ridley
(Group Amateur - 59)



Posts: 7849
  Country:
England 
Certified: 
Like this post (1)   Dislike this post (0)
Old post #23 posted Dec 4th 2014, 19:54:38 Quote 
yeah, possibly, but more than 6 seems too much, perhaps silver and gold? Although if I say that, then it would have fit into the other suggestion topic about silver stars :P
Michael Winkley
(Group Amateur - 61)



Posts: 33335
  Country:
Wales 
Certified: 
Like this post (3)   Dislike this post (0)
Old post #24 posted Dec 4th 2014, 19:57:33 Quote 
My stars already got changed once this week; are you trying to kill me?
Kirsty Ridley
(Group Amateur - 59)



Posts: 7849
  Country:
England 
Certified: 
Like this post (0)   Dislike this post (0)
Old post #25 posted Dec 4th 2014, 19:58:11 Quote 
you keep what you have, don't you? Stop whining!
Phil Maunder
(Group Pro - 12)



Posts: 10003
  Country:
England 
Certified: 
Like this post (0)   Dislike this post (0)
Old post #26 posted Dec 4th 2014, 19:59:05 Quote 
Quote ( Michael Winkley @ December 4th 2014,19:57:33 )

My stars already got changed once this week; are you trying to kill me?


At least they didnt make your stars black
Kirsty Ridley
(Group Amateur - 59)



Posts: 7849
  Country:
England 
Certified: 
Like this post (1)   Dislike this post (0)
Old post #27 posted Dec 4th 2014, 19:59:20 Quote 
how come it says 3 thumbs down, but only two names show up?
Michael Winkley
(Group Amateur - 61)



Posts: 33335
  Country:
Wales 
Certified: 
Like this post (2)   Dislike this post (0)
Old post #28 posted Dec 4th 2014, 20:01:22 Quote 
Quote ( Kirsty Ridley @ December 4th 2014,19:59:20 )

how come it says 3 thumbs down, but only two names show up?

My vote is invisible to idiots.
Phil Maunder
(Group Pro - 12)



Posts: 10003
  Country:
England 
Certified: 
Like this post (0)   Dislike this post (0)
Old post #29 posted Dec 4th 2014, 20:01:45 Quote 
Someone has / 2 thumbs?
Kirsty Ridley
(Group Amateur - 59)



Posts: 7849
  Country:
England 
Certified: 
Like this post (0)   Dislike this post (0)
Old post #30 posted Dec 4th 2014, 20:01:57 Quote 
LOL whateva! Blurgh
Page [12 3 ... 7 8 9 » Quick go to page:

Reply to this topic