| Author |
Topic: [Mafia] 2d3 (Game Over) |
1053 replies
|
|
|
Quote ( Riley Dunlop @ September 19th 2018,13:08:11 ) That is my point, I believe that scum took advantage of the push for activity to get their vote(s) on him too. Voting to get activity is not scummy itself no, but scum can take advantage of the push
That'd be fair enough, but the fact you said "probably both" were on the wagon made me think there was something more scummy you were alluding to.
|
|
|
|
Quote ( Kevin Parkinson @ September 19th 2018,09:31:21 ) Quote ( Damir Hictaler @ September 19th 2018,09:18:16 )
For now, I' ll just stick to my scum lean on you.
You're too good player and my previous post should be enough. Bringing low activity as a reason is bs.
I'm an easy target now, you decided to join Damir vagon knowing that I' m town and you dissmissed gaining town credits and defending me.
I'm positive that I have a good read/insight of yor play style.
You'll stick to your scum lean on me? Maybe I've been skimming and missed stuff but until the "WIFOM alert" post, where have you mentioned any scum lean on me for you to "stick to it"? And if you're "sticking to it", why are you not voting me?
Your previous posts should be enough for what, exactly? You'd went two days with a single post that you could even excuse as game content and you're claiming your previous posts were "enough"? Are you saying I should know you are town from your previous posts or that I shouldn't care that you were making minimal posts because you posted multiple posts one day??
I voted you to try and encourage activity from you - I can't get a read from your play if you are not playing!
Talk of knowing you are town is not any sort of case, that's a conclusion because you seem to think I am scum.
And do feel free to share how you think you have a good read or insight in to my play style and where that came from? And why you're better than much more experienced players who have openly admitted that I don't have a "play style" that would be alignment indicative?
It's hard to get rid of your scum feeling.
It' s true that comes from a previous game when you fooled all of them snd pretty much playing same game.
You can be scum, but I have also 0 exp. playing with/against him.
|
|
|
|
Quote ( Damir Hictaler @ September 19th 2018,13:26:56 ) It's hard to get rid of your scum feeling.
It' s true that comes from a previous game when you fooled all of them snd pretty much playing same game.
You can be scum, but I have also 0 exp. playing with/against him.
What??
You've not answered what I've asked.
What do you mean when you said your previous posts should have been enough? Enough for what??
And are you saying your read on me is because you're suspicious of me from a past game and not to do with this game??
And who is the "him" you have no experience of playing with?
|
|
|
|
Reading back I' ve noticed posts #300 and #301[/]
Very well placed concerned townie and question post with a theory to deflect town from truth?
IMO something a cautious scum like Ivelin would do to.
|
|
|
|
Quote ( Kevin Parkinson @ September 19th 2018,13:29:23 ) Quote ( Damir Hictaler @ September 19th 2018,13:26:56 )
It's hard to get rid of your scum feeling.
It' s true that comes from a previous game when you fooled all of them snd pretty much playing same game.
You can be scum, but I have also 0 exp. playing with/against him.
What??
You've not answered what I've asked.
What do you mean when you said your previous posts should have been enough? Enough for what??
And are you saying your read on me is because you're suspicious of me from a past game and not to do with this game??
And who is the "him" you have no experience of playing with?
Yes.
Yug.
|
|
|
|
Alo reading Yug vs Tom.
Tom is digging even bigger hole with his filler post (I'll getvrhe number), this is clearly how scum reacts, throws phrases and constructs.
Yog so far plays role of town that tries too hard. It can be hoax, so wait and see.
|
|
|
|
This is a sh*t show. I'll spell out what my reservations were about Kevin's post.
Quote ( Kevin Parkinson @ September 19th 2018,10:26:20 ) Damir, why no read on Yug when he was first to vote you for possible lurking, which you've been critical of Tom and me for?
And still leaning town on Lyee even though he put you on L-1 for the same thing (lack of content) even after your first posts today
Quote ( Damir Hictaler @ September 15th 2018,16:47:19 ) Sorry, being stuck at work.
Observations so far:
Post #37 is suspitious I agree with Ivelins thoughts.
Also post #40 is weird so early. Maybe some scum agenda.]
Lyee is kind of all over the place, maybe pretending to be Camaron.
Martin maybe exploting a bit his language barrier.
Kevin, you voting yourself was a joke or serious thought?
As can be seen here, he had doubts about Tom with respect to the concerned townie post and about Kevin from his "play style". I didn't see a post where he mentioned that he singled out Kevin and Tom because of their vote on him. I was wondering why Kevin missed that he did make a previous read and that based on what did Kevin conclude that he found Kevin/Tom scummy because of the vote.
Damir should've been the one to say this but he chose to be incoherent instead. Not sure what to make of that.
|
|
|
|
Quote ( Damir Hictaler @ September 19th 2018,13:46:16 ) Alo reading Yug vs Tom.
Tom is digging even bigger hole with his filler post (I'll getvrhe number), this is clearly how scum reacts, throws phrases and constructs.
Yog so far plays role of town that tries too hard. It can be hoax, so wait and see.
Reffering to Toms post Yug quoted in #332
|
|
|
|
Quote ( Yug Desai @ September 19th 2018,13:20:49 ) This post concerns me. I don't see the rationale for making such a post at this juncture. It does not offer any out of the box deductions either. I don't know how Riley knows "definitely" that there is a scum. It is a possibility surely, but definitely?
Where did I say that I know that there is definitely a scum?
What I actually said, which is what you quoted was:
Quote ( Riley Dunlop @ September 19th 2018,12:49:30 ) If Damir is lynched and flips town I would hazard a guess that out of the four (Yug, Kevin, Tom and Lyee) there is definitely one of the scum
Hazard a guess is definitely not saying that I know
However, your defensive reaction is interesting given that you were one of the names that I mentioned
|
|
|
|
Quote ( Kevin Parkinson @ September 19th 2018,13:21:55 ) That'd be fair enough, but the fact you said "probably both" were on the wagon made me think there was something more scummy you were alluding to.
No just a poor use of words maybe - I probably should have said "possibly" rather than "probably"
|
|
|
|
Quote ( Yug Desai @ September 19th 2018,13:46:29 ) I didn't see a post where he mentioned that he singled out Kevin and Tom because of their vote on him.
#309 - he mentions it about me (he messed the quote up and said so in the next post - the content in the middle is his response and not a quote)
#321 - he mentions it about Tom
#325 - I ask the question about his null read on you given you started the "lurking wagon" and he's just been critical of me then Tom for that
|
|
|
|
Quote ( Damir Hictaler @ September 19th 2018,13:37:24 ) Yes.
Just to point this nonsense out to everyone. Damir is confirming his read on me is because he's suspicious of me from a past game! /o\
|
|
|
|
Quote ( Yug Desai @ September 19th 2018,13:46:29 ) As can be seen here, he had doubts about Tom with respect to the concerned townie post and about Kevin from his "play style".
And nothing in your quoted post suggests doubts about my "play style". He asked a question about my self-vote, which was then answered and cleared up.
He has now since claimed "his posts were enough" and I shouldn't have voted him to try and improve his activity and that his suspicion of me is nothing to do with this game.
|
|
|
|
Quote ( Damir Hictaler @ September 19th 2018,13:35:30 ) Reading back I' ve noticed posts #300 and #301[/]
Very well placed concerned townie and question post with a theory to deflect town from truth?
IMO something a cautious scum like Ivelin would do to.
Pointing out you were on L-1 could be town as much as fake scum concern.
And talk of "a theroy to deflect town from truth"?? Ivelin joked about the odds of Tom and me being scum together again after YOUR READS!!! You were the one that said Tom and I were your scum reads! And now you try and claim Ivelin is scummy for mentioning what you just brought up??
|
|
|
|
Quote ( Kevin Parkinson @ September 19th 2018,14:48:20 ) Just to point this nonsense out to everyone. Damir is confirming his read on me is because he's suspicious of me from a past game! /o\
Yeah I noticed that. He does that all the time - I am sure I have said to him in previous games to play the game he is in
|
|
|
|
|
Quote ( Riley Dunlop @ September 19th 2018,14:35:33 ) No just a poor use of words maybe - I probably should have said "possibly" rather than "probably"
As poor as using "hazard a guess" and "definitely" in the same sentence contradicting each other?
I share Yug's concern about your post on this.
|
|
|
|
You europeans must change your time zone and post at more suitable hours,always the highest activity is when im sleeping or on the booze and then its not that easy to catch up when i wake up.....
I enjoy and would like to give an opinion of everybody as i always do,but seeing that not many people agrees with it and that today i have a busy day and wont be able to elaborate till probably late in the evening,i will give just a general opinion..
Right now my vote stays on Harsh and i wouldnt mind lynching him at any time.I wouldnt be unhappy with a Lyee,Tom or Yug lynch,but for that i would cast my vote if necessary much more towards dead line....For sure i wont vote Damir,and even if i have some concerns about some others,at this stage im not prepared to vote them.
So,unless something drastic happens dont count with my vote for anyone that i didnt mention....
|
|
|
|
Quote ( Kevin Parkinson @ September 19th 2018,14:45:16 )
#309 - he mentions it about me (he messed the quote up and said so in the next post - the content in the middle is his response and not a quote)
#321 - he mentions it about Tom Noted. I retract my statements.
Quote ( Kevin Parkinson @ September 19th 2018,14:50:57 )
And nothing in your quoted post suggests doubts about my "play style". No. That was once he was under pressure.
|
|
|
|
Quote ( Martin Irla @ September 19th 2018,15:13:03 ) I wouldnt be unhappy with a Lyee,Tom or Yug Curious to know how your thoughts on me have developed.
|
|
|
|
Quote ( Kevin Parkinson @ September 19th 2018,14:55:48 ) Quote ( Damir Hictaler @ September 19th 2018,13:35:30 )
Reading back I' ve noticed posts #300 and #301[/]
Very well placed concerned townie and question post with a theory to deflect town from truth?
IMO something a cautious scum like Ivelin would do to.
Pointing out you were on L-1 could be town as much as fake scum concern.
And talk of "a theroy to deflect town from truth"?? Ivelin joked about the odds of Tom and me being scum together again after YOUR READS!!! You were the one that said Tom and I were your scum reads! And now you try and claim Ivelin is scummy for mentioning what you just brought up??
Think about it, what is more efficient?
To bring up a subject (and suspicion), or to wait a jump on someone elses theory and stir things as cautious scum would do.
|
|
|
|
Quote ( Yug Desai @ September 19th 2018,15:38:34 ) Quote ( Martin Irla @ September 19th 2018,15:13:03 )
I wouldnt be unhappy with a Lyee,Tom or Yug Curious to know how your thoughts on me have developed.
As usual on D1,nothing much and only psicology Yug...
Theres something that doesnt add,my readings being right or wrong you are the only one that i cant get a read not even by instinct.You dont have a high activity,but neither low.I dont see a real scummy post,but not also a high scum hunting.Its like you are going unnoticed not wanting to get into trouble...Thats not a strong reason to cast a vote and thats why i named you last,but since you could have as many chances to be scum as others and i cant get a read and we are aproaching deadline,i wouldnt mind you getting lynched....
|
|
|
|
My (updated lol) reads so far:
Kevin - picks up nonsense blowing it out of proportion, justvto look lik an investigator. Real scumhunt done 0.
Tom - top scum candidate for lynch on D-1
Riley - can be both, maybe a town Riley would dissect my post more and be on my case allready, small suspition because of that.
Ivelin - hardvto read, leans scum, because his 2 posts are something a skilled scum would do (I had similar style when won as scum).
Martin - I give him benefit of a doubt and believe hes still inexperienced town.
Lyee - confusing like Cameron, but also was like that in previous games and he was town if I remember correctly.
Yug - leans town, his posts and reasoning are Ok.
Harsh- no clue.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Out for today.I' m for Tom lynch, can switch to others if newded and if I'll have access.
|
|
|
|
Quote ( Kevin Parkinson @ September 19th 2018,08:59:35 ) [Quote ( Ivelin Dobrev @ September 19th 2018,07:34:40 )
Damir is on L-1.
I would be okay with a Lyee lynch.
But still prefer a Tom lynch, I'm guessing, as you haven't moved your vote? Duuh.
|
|
|
|
Quote ( Tom Byrne @ September 19th 2018,09:50:48 ) Quote ( Harsh Sheth @ September 19th 2018,07:47:45 )
This is a joke, I get it, but frightening why?
Because it would have been an utter cakewalk. Why?
|
|
|
|
Quote ( Kevin Parkinson @ September 19th 2018,12:20:24 ) Did you realise you messed up, Lyee, or did someone tell you? I'm really not a fan of that type of shit-slinging. I know it's sarcasm, but I don't like it.
|
|
|
|
Quote ( Riley Dunlop @ September 19th 2018,13:04:49 ) When prompted you still hold info back:
Quote ( Lyee Chong @ September 19th 2018,10:15:46 )
I see thing that help my town read on Damir, and do you really want my to go further? I'm sure you can read between the lines, Riley.
|
|
|
|
Quote ( Damir Hictaler @ September 19th 2018,13:35:30 ) Reading back I' ve noticed posts #300 and #301[/]
Very well placed concerned townie and question post with a theory to deflect town from truth?
IMO something a cautious scum like Ivelin would do to. You still have trouble understanding that I (among others) play the same way when town and when scum. Those two posts would have been there regardless of alignment. First one was because effectively you were on L-1 and Lyee put you on L-1 quite carelessly. You can call it concerned town, well yeah I was concerned!
Second post was quite clearly a joke. (@Tom, see you can still make jokes if you really want)
|
|
|
|
Quote ( Kevin Parkinson @ September 19th 2018,14:48:20 ) Quote ( Damir Hictaler @ September 19th 2018,13:37:24 )
Yes.
Just to point this nonsense out to everyone. Damir is confirming his read on me is because he's suspicious of me from a past game! /o\ Noted and as Riley said, he has this tendency to rely almost entirely on (unreliable) meta.
|
|
|
|
|
I don't like the feeling of concern I'm getting from Yug's posts. It feels like everytime someone mentions him, he has to ask for reasons. I haven't seen him be like that in previous games, so I wouldn't be completely against his lynch. With that said, he's quite far behind Tom and Lyee atm.
|
|
Deutsch
Español
Română
Italiano
Português
Português
Français
Polski
Русский
Български
Македонски
Српски
Nederlands
Vlaams
Suomi
Lietuvių
Čeština
Magyar
Eesti keel
Slovenčina
Türkçe
Shqip
Ελληνικά
Hrvatski
Bahasa Melayu
Dansk
Pirate
