Grand Prix Racing Online Forum > General forum > Rules - Promotion & Relegation - error? Tambah topik ini kepada senarai abai anda Tambah topik ini kepada senarai pemerhatian anda
Halaman [1
Pengarang Topik: Rules - Promotion & Relegation - error? 19 balasan
Andrew Galica
(Kumpulan Amateur - 24)


Kiriman: 665
  Negara:
England 
Persijilan: 
Suka kiriman ini (1)   Tidak suka kiriman ini (0)
Kiriman lama #1 dikirim Okt 10 2014, 22:18:00 Sebut 
From the Rules...7.1

The top 4 managers in each group (excluding Elite) will be promoted to a randomly assigned group, one level above the level they are currently at. The bottom 16 managers from each group (excluding Rookie) will be relegated to the level below. Any manager, who finishes in the top 4, but with a negative balance, will not be promoted, and instead the next highest manager with a positive balance will be promoted in his/her place.

Shouldn't it read as follows:-

The top 4 managers in Rookie and the top 3 managers in Amateur, Pro and Master (excluding Elite) will be promoted to a randomly assigned group, one level above the level they are currently at.The bottom 15 managers from each group (excluding Rookie) will be relegated to the level below.Any manager, who finishes in the top 4 in Rookie and top 3 in Amateur, Pro and Master (excluding Elite) , but with a negative balance, will not be promoted, and instead the next highest manager with a positive balance will be promoted in his/her place.

This will apply to GPRO wiki as well, also it says. -" Promotion & Relegation "

Thanks
Zeljko Sperlic
(Kumpulan Amateur - 72)



Kiriman: 720
  Negara:
Serbia 
Persijilan: 
Suka kiriman ini (0)   Tidak suka kiriman ini (1)
Kiriman lama #2 dikirim Nov 1 2014, 17:00:01 Sebut 
I have same question? why in rules are mention 4 managers for promotion but really will be only 3 in one group. And some one on 4th place will go if have points and place is open......
where we do not see what is written with small letters?
Jukka Sireni2
(Pentadbir)



Krew GPRO
Kiriman: 3547
  Negara:
Finland 
Persijilan: 
Suka kiriman ini (0)   Tidak suka kiriman ini (0)
Kiriman lama #3 dikirim Nov 1 2014, 17:01:32 (terakhir disunting Nov 1 2014, 17:02:30 oleh Jukka Sireni) Sebut 
From the same part of the rules:

Note that in case when the groups structure of the game is under ongoing expansion, a different number of managers may be promoted in the different classes of the game.

Though expansion is completed for other groups than Rookie, so it could be changed already.
Zeljko Sperlic
(Kumpulan Amateur - 72)



Kiriman: 720
  Negara:
Serbia 
Persijilan: 
Suka kiriman ini (0)   Tidak suka kiriman ini (1)
Kiriman lama #4 dikirim Nov 1 2014, 17:12:38 Sebut 
what expansion is now? or always is expansion?
To say on end , if you are 4th do not expect to be promoted and be happy if you are promoted
George Odhis
(Kumpulan Pro - 10)



Kiriman: 317
  Negara:
Kenya 
Persijilan: 
Suka kiriman ini (0)   Tidak suka kiriman ini (0)
Kiriman lama #5 dikirim Nov 1 2014, 17:14:16 Sebut 
I changed the rules yesterday. Sorry, I don't have the rights!

On a serious note... I think lots of changes are being made in the current season. Maybe this is also on the way.
Alex Nikodem-Wing
(Kumpulan Amateur - 98)


Kiriman: 1738
  Negara:
England 
Persijilan: 
Suka kiriman ini (0)   Tidak suka kiriman ini (0)
Kiriman lama #6 dikirim Nov 1 2014, 17:18:58 Sebut 
Quote ( Jukka Sireni @ November 1st 2014,17:01:32 )

Though expansion is completed


So even if 500,000 more active players want to join we will never expand anymore
Janne Kuokkanen
(Kumpulan Amateur - 122)



Kiriman: 1224
  Negara:
Finland 
Persijilan: 
Suka kiriman ini (0)   Tidak suka kiriman ini (1)
Kiriman lama #7 dikirim Nov 1 2014, 17:53:28 Sebut 
Quote ( Alex Nikodem-Wing @ November 1st 2014,17:18:58 )


So even if 500,000 more active players want to join we will never expand anymore


expanding from what will be current maximum (1-5-25-125-600) would in my opinion mean that different amount of people promote from master to elite or we'd have 15 master groups. also remember that fir each master group you'll need to add 5 pro groups, 25 amateur groups and 125 rookie groups to keep the pyramid complete. expansion will also consume more server which means more money. the supporter cost per race could go higher than what it is now.
Tomek Kiełpiński
(Kumpulan Elite)



Kiriman: 5414
  Negara:
Poland 
Persijilan: 
Suka kiriman ini (1)   Tidak suka kiriman ini (0)
Kiriman lama #8 dikirim Nov 1 2014, 18:05:39 Sebut 
First of all the will still need 209 new rookie groups to finish the current expansion. And every new player uses some server resources, but is worth extra money for advertisers, so I can't understand why you think the supporter credits will cost more
Alex Nikodem-Wing
(Kumpulan Amateur - 98)


Kiriman: 1738
  Negara:
England 
Persijilan: 
Suka kiriman ini (0)   Tidak suka kiriman ini (0)
Kiriman lama #9 dikirim Nov 1 2014, 18:11:29 Sebut 
But the more people who pay the more supporters there would be so I think the cost would remain the same.
Michael Winkley
(Kumpulan Amateur - 61)



Kiriman: 33335
  Negara:
Wales 
Persijilan: 
Suka kiriman ini (0)   Tidak suka kiriman ini (0)
Kiriman lama #10 dikirim Nov 2 2014, 10:37:27 Sebut 
Quote ( Janne Kuokkanen @ November 1st 2014,17:53:28 )

Quote ( Alex Nikodem-Wing @ November 1st 2014,17:18:58 )


So even if 500,000 more active players want to join we will never expand anymore

expanding from what will be current maximum (1-5-25-125-600) would in my opinion mean that different amount of people promote from master to elite or we'd have 15 master groups. also remember that fir each master group you'll need to add 5 pro groups, 25 amateur groups and 125 rookie groups to keep the pyramid complete. expansion will also consume more server which means more money. the supporter cost per race could go higher than what it is now.

A Finn that got his figures wrong. A first. ;p
625 Rookie groups.
Zeljko Sperlic
(Kumpulan Amateur - 72)



Kiriman: 720
  Negara:
Serbia 
Persijilan: 
Suka kiriman ini (0)   Tidak suka kiriman ini (1)
Kiriman lama #11 dikirim Nov 17 2014, 20:22:47 Sebut 
again, when will we know is it 4 promote from Amateur in Pro or only 3 after this season 44?
Thx GPRO Crew
Fran Betancort
(Kumpulan Amateur - 66)



Kiriman: 2945
  Negara:
Sepanyol 
Persijilan: 
Suka kiriman ini (0)   Tidak suka kiriman ini (0)
Kiriman lama #12 dikirim Nov 17 2014, 20:28:28 Sebut 
Only the first 3 promote, if you don´t manage to get into those 3 you can promote with additional promotion spots.

You can check promotions at any time here:

/gb/AllPromotions.asp
Zeljko Sperlic
(Kumpulan Amateur - 72)



Kiriman: 720
  Negara:
Serbia 
Persijilan: 
Suka kiriman ini (0)   Tidak suka kiriman ini (1)
Kiriman lama #13 dikirim Nov 17 2014, 20:30:21 Sebut 
so rules must be rewritten?
Jim Sikma
(Kumpulan Amateur - 27)



Kiriman: 607
  Negara:
Amerika Syarikat 
Persijilan: 
Suka kiriman ini (0)   Tidak suka kiriman ini (0)
Kiriman lama #14 dikirim Nov 17 2014, 23:33:05 Sebut 
Further upthread is the "numbers may change during game expansion" which technically is still in progress, despite no groups being added until the existing rookie groups have fuller fields.

Currently it's 3 from Master/Pro/Amateur, and 4 from Rookie.
Andrew Galica
(Kumpulan Amateur - 24)


Kiriman: 665
  Negara:
England 
Persijilan: 
Suka kiriman ini (2)   Tidak suka kiriman ini (0)
Kiriman lama #15 dikirim Nov 18 2014, 01:16:22 (terakhir disunting Nov 18 2014, 01:17:06 oleh Andrew Galica) Sebut 
Rules have now been updated.

7.1 Promotion/Relegation

The top 3 managers in each group (excluding Elite) will be promoted to a randomly assigned group, one level above the level they are currently at. The bottom 15 managers from each group (excluding Rookie) will be relegated to the level below. Any manager, who finishes in the top 3, but with a negative balance, will not be promoted, and instead the next highest manager with a positive balance will be promoted in his/her place. Any manager who finishes with a negative balance shall be relegated to the division below. The highest placed manager in the relegation zone will remain in their group as a result.

Note that in case when the groups structure of the game is under ongoing expansion, a different number of managers may be promoted in the different classes of the game.


Zeljko Sperlic
(Kumpulan Amateur - 72)



Kiriman: 720
  Negara:
Serbia 
Persijilan: 
Suka kiriman ini (0)   Tidak suka kiriman ini (3)
Kiriman lama #16 dikirim Nov 18 2014, 08:42:04 Sebut 
Quote ( Zeljko Sperlic @ November 17th 2014,20:30:21 )

so rules must be rewritten?


Game Rules
Last Updated: Yesterday At 22:34:16

Thx GPRO crew for update, now need to fight more for 3rd place.
Andrew Galica
(Kumpulan Pro - 14)


Kiriman: 665
  Negara:
England 
Persijilan: 
Suka kiriman ini (4)   Tidak suka kiriman ini (0)
Kiriman lama #17 dikirim Nov 7 2015, 23:36:17 Sebut 
And once again we find ourselves here !

Please can we correct the rule to reflect the current situation - ref Amateur relegation number from bottom 15 to 10.

Thank you.

Also while I am here can we please remove the ambiguous and blatantly lazy solution to a non static scenario that cannot be considered a rule condition, namely :- Note that in case when the groups structure of the game is under ongoing expansion or reduction, a different number of managers may be promoted or relegated in the different classes of the game.

This cannot be considered a rule condition as it is too ambiguous, and is clearly outside the confines of a rule definition.

:)
Tajinder Singh
(Kumpulan Rookie - 261)



Kiriman: 1220
  Negara:
India 
Persijilan: 
Suka kiriman ini (0)   Tidak suka kiriman ini (0)
Kiriman lama #18 dikirim Jun 19 2016, 07:27:47 Sebut 
the rule about this should be updated. there are groups where 6-15 relegate. why the rule is confusing!
Vitaly Sevov
(Kumpulan Amateur - 47)



Kiriman: 192
  Negara:
Federasi Russia 
Persijilan: 
Suka kiriman ini (0)   Tidak suka kiriman ini (0)
Kiriman lama #19 dikirim Ogo 14 2019, 13:22:26 Sebut 
Is there any option finishing in top 4, to not being promoted from Amateur to Pro other than having a negative balance?
Something like writing a letter saying " I got in top 4 by mistake , let me stay in Amateur for one season more, please" ?
Robin Goodey
(Kumpulan Master - 2)



Kiriman: 1862
  Negara:
England 
Persijilan: 
Suka kiriman ini (3)   Tidak suka kiriman ini (0)
Kiriman lama #20 dikirim Ogo 14 2019, 13:31:42 Sebut 
Short answer - no
Halaman [1
Grand Prix Racing Online Forum > General forum > Rules - Promotion & Relegation - error? Tambah topik ini kepada senarai abai anda Tambah topik ini kepada senarai pemerhatian anda

Balas topik ini